Downtown parking panel discussion via video conference scheduled for May 6, 5 pm – POSTPONED

Britt Ackerman Mary Closner Ross Currier Leota Goodney

Chris Heineman Christopher Tassava Steve Wilmot

We’re hosting a live video conference today, May 6, at 5 pm to discuss the DRAFT “final” report on the Downtown Parking Conversation. The draft is on the agenda for the City Council work session on Tuesday, May 14th.

Panelists confirmed thus far:

We’ll be using Google+ Hangout Air for the video conference, embedded right here on the downtown parking conversation blog.  If you’re unable to attend the live conference, I’ll have it archived here for you shortly after it’s over.

There are three ways for you to participate in this event:

  1. We’ll be using an online text chat feature so that anyone can submit questions for the panel during the video conference.
  2. You can submit questions for the panel ahead of time by either attaching a comment to this blog post, or by using the Contact Us form
  3. After the panel is over, we’ll continue the discussion via blog comment thread till Friday, May 10, possibly later.

Got questions or suggestions? Attach a comment or contact me.

Update 4:30 pm:

Unfortunately, some panelists has to cancel this afternoon at the last minute so we’re canceling the video conference for today and will have an update soon on when it’ll be rescheduled.

My apologies for the hassle. Enjoy the gorgeous spring weather!

Draft Report on Downtown Parking Conversation

NDDC_Parking_Conversation_Draft_April24_2013Here is our DRAFT "final" report on the Downtown Parking Conversation.  I’ve also sent it out via email to all of the participants in the stakeholder gatherings for feedback before formal submission to the City Council.

We have attempted to highlight and prioritize the ideas/recommendations from a wide variety of stakeholders/users. 

DowntownParkingDiscussionAppendixPlease note that the raw "data" of ideas is included as an appendix.  We are particularly interested in hearing if we have not adequately raised the visibility of key ideas.

Please share your feedback on the report with us by Friday, May 3rd.  We will do our best to incorporate what we hear from you in the report presented to the Council.  

You can submit feedback, ask questions, and engage in discussion via the comment thread attached to this blog post.  You can also use the form on the Contact Us page.

Also, our online coordinator Griff Wigley will soon have an announcement about a panel discussion via live video conference early next week, so watch for that.

April 3 parking management planning meeting at City Hall

Jerry Bilek, Ross Currier, Tim Madigan, Jessica Peterson-White, David DeLongWe held a parking management plan meeting on April 3.  NDDC Board Member Jerry Bilek and I were there representing the NDDC.

City staff included City Administrator Tim Madigan, Community Planning & Development Director Chris Heineman, and Public Works Director/City Engineer Joe Stapf.

City Councilors David DeLong and Jessica Peterson-White (members of the Council’s Downtown Parking Subcommittee) attended along with online citizen engagement consultant Griff Wigley.

After we discussed the 12/11/12 Council meeting decision to charge the NDDC with the Downtown Parking Study, the 12/17/12 meeting to fine-tune the assignment, and the 1/16/13 meeting to add specifics to the process, I summarized past meetings with stakeholder groups and identified upcoming stakeholder group meetings and suggested that the ideas shared by the various stakeholder groups be organized in three categories:

  • Physical Projects
  • Process Improvements
  • Educational Initiatives and Macro Concepts

The Councilors asked if specific recommendations were emerging. I said that repeated ideas, or common themes, included enforcement of existing regulations, increasing the diversity of time limits, and reinforcing awareness of the regulations through increased education.

The Council members followed up with a question on the time limit recommendation and I highlighted the diversity of users and needs, including pick-ups and drop-offs, residents, overnight guests, library users, and program students. The goal is to more precisely meet the specific needs of different populations of parking users.

The Councilors suggested their particular interest in common ideas, “out-of-the-box” ideas, and the NDDC’s recommended ideas. The Councilors thought that instead of presenting the report at the end of April, that the report should be circulated among stakeholder participants and that the “team” (the NDDC, City staff, and Griff Wigley) work to generate feedback on the draft as well as any additional ideas.

I agreed to finalize a draft report for circulation after the final stakeholder meeting is held. City staff and Griff will collaborate to generate additional discussion.

Northfield News article: Downtown Northfield parking conversation nears its end

In yesterday’s Northfield News, reporter Kaitlyn Walsh (@NFNKaitlyn) has an article titled Downtown Northfield parking conversation nears its end.

Northfield NewsWith the majority of key stakeholder groups consulted at face-to-face gatherings and various online forums, such as blog discussions and a straw poll, the Northfield Downtown Development Corporation will soon present its findings on how the city can deal with its current stock of spaces…

Another in-person gathering is in the works with those involved with visitor activities, such as the Northfield Arts Guild and the Defeat of Jesse James Days Committee, he said. Other stakeholder gatherings included building owners, bicycle and pedestrian commuters, business owners and residential neighbors.

Currier said that ideas seemed to fall into three categories: Physical projects, such as re-striping spaces; process improvements, including better enforcement of existing regulations; and education, which could mean distributing maps that show short- and long-term parking or boosting awareness of laws related to crosswalks.

(continued)

March 28 discussion of parking issues for downtown area residents

DSC09236 DSC09235 DSC09234
A small (but influential!) group gathered at the Northfield Public Library last Thursday evening for a discussion of parking issues relevant to those who live in or near downtown.  Ross Currier hosted the meeting and I was  the designated photographer.

This was the 5th of several stakeholder group meetings that have been held since the project started. See all the stakeholder-related blog posts and see Ross’ Jan. 24 blog post, Planning for stakeholder input on downtown parking management.

The group generated a list of items they they’d like to see discussed. Here’s Ross’ post-meeting translation:

  • Expected more parking disruptions than have experienced
  • Sunday morning (church) busiest time
  • Wonder about Premier Bank lot availability
  • Increased enforcement of parking limits would help
  • Workers who walk or ride impacted by weather
  • Need a culture change about acceptable distance for parking
  • Library’s short-term spaces taken by all-day parkers
  • Library has no parking for late morning or afternoon programs (all taken)
  • Parking is #1 complaint for library patrons
  • City purchase of apartment building is a real opportunity for library
  • Need parking for out-of-town visitors
  • Visitors can help drive the economy
  • Need better signage for public parking locations
  • Downtown residents are really affected by parking regulations
  • Parking regulations should be supportive of downtown residents
  • Collaborate with Carleton on Division Street north of 2nd Street
  • Try valet parking during big downtown events
  • Library parking has been an issue for 28 years
  • Library has programs that serve 40 people – there aren’t 40 free spaces
  • Changing demographics impact parking needs
  • Older people, toddlers find longer walks more challenging
  • Need some dedicated library parking
  • Try some “Library Parking Only” signs
  • Use smart library cards for parking
  • Three public lots at 3rd Street perfect for parking experiments
  • Seniors look for parking and if they don’t see it they’ll drive away

Residential stakeholders to share experiences and ideas on Mar. 28

Make It BBQAt the direction of the Northfield City Council, and in collaboration with the staff of the City of Northfield, the Northfield Downtown Development Corp. (NDDC) has been conducting a Downtown Parking Conversation.  The goal is to gather downtown stakeholders together and generate ideas for better use of our downtown parking resources.

The Council, City and NDDC want to hear the thoughts of the residents in the neighborhood near downtown.  We’ve heard that downtown parking is part of many of these residents’ daily lives and that they may have some parking stories and ideas to share with us.  It’s important that the downtown neighbors are part of the parking discussion.

The Residential Stakeholder Gathering will be Thursday, March 28th, 7:00 p.m., at the Northfield Public Library.  Please, join us in the discussion of downtown parking.  If you are unable to join us, but have thoughts and ideas that you’d like to share, stay tuned to this blog and we’ll have online ways for you to contribute.

Here’s Griff Wigley’s photo of me distributing invitation cards to residential addresses near downtown last week:

Ross Currier, delivering invitations Invitation to downtown residential stakeholders

Business owners discuss parking issues at Mar. 19 meeting at Archer House

DowntownBusinessOwnersParkingDiscussion 20130320_071739 20130320_071751 20130320_071803
A group of 18 local business owners met in the Archer House conference room on Tuesday morning to discuss downtown parking issues. Ross Currier hosted the meeting was called upon to be the designated photographer as I had a family medical appointment in the Twin Cities.

This was the 4th of several stakeholder group meetings that have been held since the project started. See all the stakeholder-related blog posts and see Ross’ Jan. 24 blog post, Planning for stakeholder input on downtown parking management.

The group generated a list of items they they’d like to see discussed. Ross will have the post-meeting translation written up early next week and I’ll post it here. Here’s Ross’ post-meeting translation:

  • Customers and Residents Compete for Parking
  • There are Both Short-Term vs. Long-Term Parking Needs
  • Pick-Ups and Drop-Offs Need Very Short-Term Parking
  • Both Residents and Workers are Important to the Economy
  • Many Residents Don’t Have Dedicated Spots
  • What are the Needs of Residents and Workers?
  • People are Staying More Nights at the Archer House
  • We Need Some Overnight Guest Parking on Division Street
  • Residents (Rental) are a Steady Income Stream
  • Pursue Private-Public Partnerships to Create More Parking
  • Our Aging Population Impacts Parking
  • Older People Don’t Want to Walk as Far
  • Parking Terms (Long and Short) Might Benefit from Adjustment
  • However, Enforcement is the Key
  • Two Hours of Turnover in the Morning (Busier Some Places)
  • One and a Half Hour “Rush” at Lunch
  • One and a Half Hour “Rush” at Dinner
  • Sometimes Several Hour “Rush” at Night
  • Consider One-Way Streets and Diagonal Parking? No!
  • Consider Returning Parking Meters? No!
  • Study Edina Model – Who Paid for It?
  • Build Additional Levels on Public Parking Lots
  • Red Wing: Public Sector Support Private Sector with Parking
  • Stillwater: How Do They Choose the Mix of Free and Pay Parking?
  • Some Retailers Have More “Visitor” Customers on Weekends
  • Paint “Customer” Label on Painted Stripes
  • Add Some 30-Minute Parking Spaces
  • Explore Area Wide Plan for Westside with MOM?
  • Consider “Re-lining” Spaces for Better Use?
  • Consider Bigger, Longer Plan for Parking in Downtown (More Money, More Parking)
  • Explore Short-Term Plan with Premier Bank?
  • Remember West Side of Highway 3
  • Speed of Traffic on Hwy 3 Limits Economic Development
  • Leverage EDA Resources for Parking
  • Are There Opportunities on The Crossing Site?
  • Can We Get More Economic Leverage from North Hwy 3?
  • Economic Drivers (Commercial Property Taxes) Pay for Everything

More downtown parking stakeholder discussions scheduled. Next up: business owners on March 19

art-jetson-hb1The NDDC-City of Northfield collaborative downtown parking discussion continues.  In coming weeks, additional important stakeholder groups will gather to share insights and ideas.

Next up is the downtown business owners’ stakeholder group.  On Tuesday, March 19th, 8:00 a.m., the downtown business owners will gather at the Archer House to discuss downtown parking.

This is obviously a very important stakeholder group.  We’re looking forward to hearing their observations and suggestions as part of the on-going downtown parking discussion.

Stillwater’s downtown parking lots, ramp, rules

A March 9 article in the StarTribune titled Downtown Stillwater without the lift bridge? Maybe better than ever? discusses what the city is doing to prepare for the day when Hwy. 36 commuter traffic no longer travels through downtown.

Stillwater downtown parking map and rulesIt might be interesting to follow those developments but in the meantime, I found this Stillwater downtown parking map on their website. It includes info on their parking lots (free parking, limited free parking, pay parking, permit parking) and their parking ramp. In addition, the map has this:

  • Posted time limits will be enforced year round
  • Stillwater is a handicap friendly city with 31 designated spots. All city owned lots have handicapped parking.
  • All on street parking is three hour limit unless otherwise designated. Posted time limits will be enforced year round.

Downtown Stillwater is different from downtown Northfield, of course, but might there be something we can learn from what’s working and not working there?

Focused blog discussions till March 10

For the next week (and maybe longer), we’ve got three focused blog discussion threads active here. Although each one addresses the concerns of the particular stakeholder group, the discussions are open to all:online engagement

Chime in!

Recent Comments

  • Blog discussion: parking issues relevant to bicyclists (23)
    • Lee Gifford: hmm… “head-out” parking really sounds like a great idea! However I would only be in favor of the change if the downtown took the proper planning to see if all sections of downtown parking could be safely converted...
    • Griff Wigley: Lee, welcome to Northfield! And thanks much for taking the time to compose such a thoughtful and detailed comment. I’ve moved it from the straw poll blog to this discussion thread since most of your comments are about biking....
    • Lee Gifford: I recently moved to Northfield from downtown Minneapolis for reason that would involve a long long story which I don’t think is to important. I was really surprised at how much Northfield has to offer! Granted I mostly drive...
    • Sean Hayford Oleary: Yes. I suppose the most neutral term for this type facility would simply be “shoulder” — though that usually suggests a rural road, where on-street parking would be virtually non-existent.
    • Griff Wigley: And in effect, that’s what Jefferson Road has on the west side of the street, right?
  • Take the Northfield downtown parking straw poll (7)
    • Griff Wigley: The Northfield News is conducting an online straw poll: “How often do you have trouble finding a parking space downtown?” See their right sidebar.
    • Griff Wigley: The straw poll is now closed. I expect to have the results posted by Monday morning.
    • Griff Wigley: I plan to end the straw poll tonight at midnight. So if you’ve not yet taken in, now’s the time. I’ll then blog the results, along with the submitted comments. And then we can refer to it as needed when we started...
    • Griff Wigley: 63 respondents to the straw poll thus far, with lots of comments. I’m thinking I’ll keep it open till next weekend.
    • Griff Wigley: Dan, glad you chimed in. Did you take the poll as well? I added a section there based on your face-to-face comment in GBM last week. Dean, it never occurred to me that we’d have non-vehicle owners taking the parking poll but I...
  • Focused blog discussions till March 10 (1)
    • Griff Wigley: We’ve extended the blog discussions for another ten days.
  • Blog discussion: parking issues relevant to pedestrians (14)
    • George Kinney: No — I haven’t looked into that, I’ll see if I can find anything. As far as training drivers, I’ve often thought it interesting that we work to get the 15-year-olds fully educated, then turn them loose until...
    • Griff Wigley: George, are you aware of any education campaigns that have been deemed effective, not just about crosswalks but about the “complete streets” movement?
    • George Kinney: Education is needed. As some readers/participants know,I teach the AARP Drivers Safety courses, and many drivers are unaware that they must yield to pedestrians in all crosswalks (at any intersection). Many believe that the only...
    • Griff Wigley: Steve, in your walks around downtown are there any other intersections that you think need 4-way or even 2-way stop signs?
    • Griff Wigley: George, that happened to me and Robbie a couple years ago at the intersection of 5th and Division. Fortunately, a Northfield cop watched it happened and immediately pulled over the offender. As a regular biker and walker, do you...
  • Blog discussion: parking issues relevant to downtown building owners (7)
    • Griff Wigley: I’ve gotten some parking-related comments to my recent post on the Locally Grown Facebook page wall. Three people said they never have trouble finding a parking spot downtown. I’ll copy/paste my replies here for the...
    • Griff Wigley: Jim, ‘extortion’ and ‘violence’ are two words I’ve not heard in connection to parking meters, Cool Hand Luke (video link) not withstanding. ;-) But you didn’t say why you see parking meters in such...
    • James Rossow: Parking meters is a form of legal extortion. Putting parking meters downtown will change the profile of downtown in a negative fashion. It is a form of municipal violence. Don’t do it.
    • Griff Wigley: Krin, good to have a longtime downtown retailer chiming in here. Do you think we need hard data on the amount of downtown parking enforcement that’s done each year (eg, citations issued, revenue collected, repeat offenders,...
    • Krin Finger: Education & Enforcement: I’ve attended 1 or 2 parking task force meetings throughout my 25+ years ‘parked’ on Division Street. Each one ends the same: final cost breakdown of adding more parking and...
  • Creating public awareness of the downtown parking management project (1)
    • Griff Wigley: I’ve continued to post updates on the latest developments with this project: * Twitter account @Nfld_Parking, retweeted by @LoGroNfld * Comments to the blog post on Locally Grown * Comments to the  blog post on Northfield.org *...
  • Northfield Downtown Parking straw poll results (82 responses) (3)
    • Griff Wigley: For convenience and quoting, here are the responses to the Straw Poll Item/Question 13 (What other comments do you have related to non-motorized transportation and downtown? Northfield is small enough, compact enough and its...
    • Griff Wigley: For convenience and quoting, here are the responses to the Straw Poll Item/Question 12 (What would encourage you to use non-motorized means to get downtown more often? Or conversely, what are the obstacles that discourage you from...
    • Griff Wigley: For convenience and quoting, here are the responses to the Straw Poll Item/Question 8 (comments on anything related to Parking Habits items 1-7: I don’t usually have a problem finding a parking spot fairly close to my...
  • Pedestrians to meet, offer input on downtown parking. What’s a walking shed? (2)
    • Griff Wigley: No problem that you missed the gathering, Beth. We’ll have a follow-up blog discussion thread here in the near future.
    • Beth Kallestad: Griff – unfortunately can’t make it (some of us have to work :) ) Looking forward to seeing what others have to say on this topic. We chose our current house location and will most likely choose our next based on the...
  • Help design the downtown parking online straw poll (20)
    • Griff Wigley: With a few final adjustments, the straw poll is now live. See the blog post and click to it from there and let me know if anything seems amiss. http://northfieldparking.wordp ress.com/2013/01/28/take-the-n orthfield-downtown-parkin...
    • Griff Wigley: I’ve done a little more tinkering with the straw poll and plan to launch it tomorrow. Changes I’ve made: * I’ve added “Give up and go elsewhere” as a third option to #7: What do you typically do when you...
    • Griff Wigley: Dean, thanks for the thoughtful, detailed comment. We are in the final edits on an FAQ page that will answer some of your questions, so I’ll reply to you here as soon as I have that up. But in the meantime, be sure to read what...
    • Griff Wigley: Randy, you wrote: ” Encouraging more discussion without a shared set of facts is like inviting people to a book group with no expectation that they will first read the book. That’s silly.” No it isn’t. It’s...
    • Griff Wigley: Randy, If you look at the consensus statement of the Council parking committee and the NDDC (PDF) at: http://northfieldparking.files .wordpress.com/2012/12/downtow n-northfield-parking-conversat ion-12-18-12-update.pdf you’ll...
  • Project for Public Spaces has ideas about parking management (2)
    • Griff Wigley: Kiffi, the Council wants a management plan for the existing parking. We really won’t be discussing developing or building anything during the course of this project.
    • kiffisumma: So … can the conversation be had as to what can we do to enhance what is there, potentially not fully developed, and forget building anything? There’s no $$ anyway; neither in the city’s, nor the building owner’s...
  • Wider sidewalks vs. a parking crunch: St. Paul’s Lowertown may have lessons for Northfield (2)
    • Griff Wigley: Kiffi, this is the basic site! Everything happens here. The city is in the middle of putting up their new website platform any day now and we’ll have them link here as soon as that happens.
    • kiffisumma: Where is the basic site for this parking discussion located??? It does not come up with a search on the City’s website, and is not on the Home page??? Kiffi
  • The NDDC wants you to join “The Conversation” on downtown parking management (17)
    • Ross Currier: Stephanie - Enforcing the the posted parking limits is a classic parking management technique. I’m looking forward to hearing from the retailers on any thoughts or concerns regarding the two hour limit. Thanks so much for...
    • Stephanie Carlson: What if…we would actually enforce the 2 hour parking limit on Division Street. I work downtown and see the same folks parking ALL DAY on Division Street, and often I see cars parked downtown overnight. Just thinking that...
    • Griff Wigley: David, I did get a copy from Tim Madigan today. Thx!
    • David Ludescher: Griff – I deleted it. I will see if Mr. Madigan has a copy.
    • Griff Wigley: Thanks, David. Can you forward the email from the City Attny to me via private email? I’m doing a series of presentations for the League of MN Cities and I’ll see if I can get them to help us out on this.
  • Northfield News article on parking management (2)
    • Ross Currier: Margit - Way cool. I’ll see if Chris Heineman or Joe Stapf can get their hands on that information. Thanks much, Ross
    • Margit Johnson: Ross, my long term memory is vague, but there is another parking study sitting on a shelf somewhere in City Hall. I recall serving on a downtown transportation and parking task force some time in the 1980’s. I have no recollection...
  • How is this engagement project going to work? (2)
    • Ross Currier: Dean - The context of my titling businesses as “stars” was in reaction to the suggestion that we would ultimately consider tearing down all the buildings to create unlimited parking. Of course, I don’t think the...
    • Dean Kjerland: NDDC Executive Director Ross Currier, and I assume it reflects the NDDC’s Board and supporters, stated on the Home/Blog tab on this Parking Management website that ‘the “stars” of downtown are the retailers, restaurants,...
  • New FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions) page now up (2)
    • Ross Currier: Dean - GREAT IDEA. Thanks SO much. Chris - Let’s talk with Joe about this contact info.
    • Dean Kjerland: Griff, regarding your FAC #4, I might add data from a 12/9/2012 email from the City Engineering Dept, ‘To All Downtown [winter] Parking Permit Holders’: the list includes 47 emails – and I know that some of them...